For the first time in years, Easter will fall on the same day for both Catholic and Orthodox Christians, and one local church is embracing the occasion with tradition, reverence, and growth.

St. Nicholas Orthodox Church, located off East Ave. in Erie, is preparing for Holy Week with its long-standing custom of homemade Easter bread. The braided loaves are baked in the church’s lower level by members of the congregation, continuing a cherished tradition that connects generations.

The Mihaly family, including four young boys, brings energy and youth to the church community. Father Nick Mihaly and his wife have played a key role in revitalizing the congregation since arriving in Erie in 2016. The American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese priest says he always felt called to serve.

“I don’t remember a time of not wanting to be a priest,” Father Mihaly said.

The church’s roots go back more than 80 years, and its stunning interior reflects that history. Jim DeHaven, a lifelong member whose grandparents were among the founding families, recalls the church being hand-painted over many years by a Pittsburgh artist.

“The icons are not just pictures,” DeHaven said. “They’re written by an artist infused with the spirit.”

While deeply connected to tradition, the church is also focused on community involvement and future growth. Father Mihaly has helped organize local Easter egg hunts and a “car, food and cruise” event at the church’s secondary property, St. Nick’s Grove.

“We do see a future there for a building—a church that would fit in with the property,” Father Mihaly said. “It wouldn’t be a great monstrosity. It would be a nice country church that brings in elements of local architecture and traditional Orthodox articles, to really make it a church for Erie.”

As Easter Sunday approaches on April 20, the congregation at St. Nicholas will celebrate not only the resurrection of Christ, but also the renewal of their community and faith.